SALT LAKE CITY (AP) A Utah decide was contemplating Wednesday whether or not an 18-yr-previous accused of filming the suicide of a highschool classmate ought to stand trial for homicide after prosecutors stated he purchased a rope and helped the woman tie a noose earlier than she hanged herself.
Each side gave their ultimate arguments Tuesday in what prosecutors stated is the primary case in Utah by which somebody is accused of aiding and recording a suicide.
Decide James Brady is predicted to rule within the coming days.
Defendant Tyerell Przybycien is not accused of wielding a homicide weapon, however prosecutors argued that he is nonetheless answerable for the demise of a troubled woman who he pushed into taking her personal life.
“He had a fascination with demise,” prosecutor Chad Grundander stated. “He used her suicidal ideations for his personal functions.”
Protection attorneys countered that sixteen-yr-previous Jchandra Brown made her personal selection on Might 6 in a canyon about 60 miles (ninety six.fifty six kilometers) south of Salt Lake Metropolis.
Przybycien’s position wasn’t commendable, nevertheless it did not quantity to homicide both, his lawyer Gregory Stewart stated.
“Whereas we do not have all of the video tapes we’d like, I feel it is clear that … she was immediately concerned within the actions that brought about her demise,” he stated, in line with the Every day Herald in Provo.
The Related Press doesn’t sometimes determine juveniles in crime instances, however Brown’s mom has stated she needed her daughter to be recognized to stop something comparable from occurring once more.
Prosecutors say Przybycien purchased the rope, helped the woman tie a noose and recorded a ten-minute cellphone video of her with the rope tied round her neck earlier than she inhaled compressed air from a canister and fell unconscious.
The case carries echoes of Michelle Carter, a Massachusetts lady who inspired her suicidal boyfriend to kill himself in dozens of textual content messages when she was a young person. She was convicted of involuntary manslaughter.
The authorized distinction between homicide and involuntary manslaughter is the defendant’s psychological state, Daniel Medwed, a regulation professor at Northeastern College, informed the AP.
Homicide is intentional, whereas manslaughter usually includes extra reckless conduct corresponding to drunk driving.
Przybycien “type of set the wheels in movement, however there’s an issue with causation as a result of she made the last word choice to take her personal life,” Medwed stated.
Prosecutors say Przybycien laid out his intentions in Fb messages…